BAKER BOYS has my vote, both for their Baked Goods & their homemade Frozen Custard!

I love the cupcakes from Turtle's.

Marla's sweet bites is my all time favorite. Fresh tasting, lot's of varieties, from American butter cream to Italian buttercream to whipped. Different sizes, holiday favorites. Each day offers a different flavor. If you have a craving or a big sweet tooth Marla's is the place.

You say this is a hard question to answer....WRONG! It's the Baker Boys in a landslide. The freshness, textures, selections of their baked goods (cupcakes, scones, croissants, brownies, cookies, cheesecakes, muffins, eclairs) and frozen custards are unsurpassed, not to mention the smooth Julius Meinl coffee!

No question baker boys is the best place satisfy your sweet tooth in the north shore.

No Maria's bakery in Highwood.......I mean come on.

No doubt I'm a "Baker Nut". Baker Boys has the best treats in town. If I am blowing my diet it is definitely with a BB red velvet cupcake. Or maybe a banana chocolate chip cupcake. Or maybe with a peanut buttercup cookie. Or maybe..... you get the idea!

Sorry all, Marla's takes the Cup Cake in this competition. I understand all the faithful BB customers but overall taste, flavor and creativity goes to Marla's in Highland Park.

BAKER BOYS!!!!

Bent Fork in Highwood tops them all. GHK

With a Spring that has already felt like Summer and the actual Summer season right around the corner, I look forward to the tasty treats of Frost! The gelato is fantastic, the service is spectacular and the atmosphere is unique. I can't wait to try yet another of Frost's delicious flavors! Yum!

Actually I am tried of all of this cupcake wars. We all have our favorites so let's just go there and endulge.

Im voting for Frost Gelato. it is the best Gelato place in the entire world.

Highland Park Pop...a great addition

Frost! No question about it.

the cheesecakes at baker boys are pretty amazing. sure, i like ice cream too, but if i indulge in a real dessert it would be that amazing cheesecake.
they offer a few flavors, all delish.

DAIRY QUEEN!!! If you are going to include Dairy effin Queen then McDonald's should be included. And why not just include 7 eleven donuts. Or Walgreens have those cookies at the cash register.
Baker Boys win, even if turtles pathetic owner votes 100 times and the brain dead continue to vote for dairy queen.

FROST GELATO is BY FAR the best dessert spot in HP!

It's clearly evident by now that there should have been different categories for this poll...one for frozen desserts and another for baked goods! Then, Baker Boys would clearly win in one category and Frost in the other. However, it's grossly unfair for the the many great independent entrepreneurs in Highland Park to be pitted against the franchise giants like Frost (over 600 locations) and Dairy Queen (over 5,900 locations). It's obvious that these two have "stacked the deck" and encouraged votes from across the country which should be a no-no! I sincerely hope that all this is recognized and addressed in the poll results and any subsequent articles in the Highland Park Patch.

Wow, Doug! I thought the same thing all along! Baked goods & frozen desserts should be separate categories . I had no idea everyone was so passionate about their choices. HEY JACOB NELSON/HP Patch - its not too late to re-think your categories!

Frost is by far the best. Not only is it delicious, but it is a treat for the eyes. I just love the display of the gelato! I can't get enough!!!

What's wrong with this picture? Arriva Dolce goes from almost no votes to more than 500 within just a few hours?! Let's just drop this poll and admit that there are many places in Highland Park where people enjoy desserts, whether baked or frozen, and leave it at that! You're right...this poll is NOT scientific!

This is hardly a fair poll to ANY of the HP entrepreneurs. Someone told me they were able to vote for the same store 5 times in a row.

I LOVE BAKER BOYS CUPCAKES!

Baker boys has the best sweet treats ever!!

Baker Boys has a wide variety of treats, it can not even be listed on the scale of dessert places that serve solely ice cream or solely cupcakes because frankly Baker Boys has all of it and it's better!

Baker boys!

Forget all of these - go to City Park Grill for bread pudding and the best warm chocolate brownie desert in town!

Thanks for the response, Jacob.