.
Feedback

Katie, Oprah and the Slutty Brownie Divide

On a 14-hour drive back to the North Shore from Ohio after dropping her daughter off at college, Sally Higginson reflects on the chief difference between two daytime talk show hosts.

What’s the difference between Katie and Oprah? The slutty brownie.

On the first episode of her new syndicated talk show, Katie Couric’s guest, Jessica Simpson, confessed a weakness for them. To the uninitiated, slutty brownies are a baked concoction featuring an indulgent mixture of brownie batter, chocolate chip cookie dough and Oreo cookie crumbles. What’s not to love?

But when Katie heard them described, she proffered a mock-gag.

Oprah would have been salivating, begging for a bite or even admitting to having a batch in her pantry. She would have had some on set and taken a bite on camera, connecting with Simpson and everyone else watching.

I’m not saying that every woman dreams slutty brownie dreams. But no woman I know – no woman I can relate to – thinks they sound gross.

Honestly, they sound like atomic-level comfort food, soft and gooey and so sublime a combination of everything that smells good while baking that I don’t know what type of person would find them repellent.

Hasn’t Katie ever baked a batch of nutrition-free, sugar-laden, chocolate-laced food? More to the point, hasn’t she ever tucked into a batch of anything, fresh from the oven?

What does Katie do when she’s just dropped off her youngest at college? Go for a jog?

Here’s what I know: the single worst food choice ever is the Bloomin’ Onion at The Outback Steakhouse. Here’s what else I know: coming in at an artery-clogging, calorie-crazed, healthy-choice-violating second is anything from the counter at Cinnabon.

Their tag line? “Life needs frosting.” If this were a religion, I’d convert. Baptism by icing sounds divine. 

Katie, clearly, is not a member of this congregation.

Me? Suffice it to say that somewhere on the Ohio Turnpike, I found my resistance weakened and my resolve lost. Ten hours earlier I had kissed my youngest goodbye on the sloping fields in front of her dorm. She had a new life to start, and I had a 14-hour drive back home.

Maybe at the start of my drive I might have had a little bit in common with Katie. I’m an adult American woman, and a lifetime member of Weight Watchers, which means that I know what constitutes a good choice, a better choice, and a train wreck. I don’t know about the success of trickledown economics, but trickledown health-onomics is securely in place in a land where Happy Meals come with apples and carrots and a joy-free, taste-free salad is available wherever you stop to fill your tank.

In other words, if you want to make a “Katie” choice, you have options.

Back at the Ohio Oasis, I found myself staring down the salads while mentally lingering on that last hug goodbye at the campus I’d left hours and hours ago.

That’s when I realized there was no line at the Cinnabon counter.

I walked over like an alcoholic walking into a bar and claiming to want a Diet Coke. Ha. I knew what I had come for, and $3.49 later, I had it.

Disclosure: I have done the research and here’s what I know: the caffeine buzz from an iced Grande Skim Latte does not successfully counter the gluttonous food stupor that a strip of mini-Cinnabons induces. Put more succinctly, it’s not that easy to get back into the hot car on an 82 degree day and feel perky after adding so much frosting to one’s life. 

Well, if Katie Couric is anything, it’s perky. So I guess Cinnabons, or slutty brownies, are not her go-to comfort food.

Judging from the proliferation of online devotion to slutty brownies, and the success of the Cinnabon franchises, I’m pretty sure Katie is the exception. 

If she wants to connect to her audience, maybe she should indulge every now and then. So Katie, if you’re reading, here’s the recipe. I don’t recommend them all the time. But after you drop a child at college, or maybe when that daughter comes home, why not bake a batch?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Highland Park Patch? Find your Local Patch »

D'skidoc September 15, 2012 at 11:02 am
Fresh and warm out of the oven with a scoop and a half of french vanilla on top. But don't do this while driving, since it would constitute a distraction and also a coma inducer.
AJ September 15, 2012 at 03:55 pm
I prefer my thick, gooey sugar-laden treats one flavor at a time -- give me a brownie, a Cinnabon, or a chocolate chip cookie -- but not all at once, and especially not with Oreos on top. The only thing I want with my Oreos is a glass of milk.
Guido McGinty September 15, 2012 at 09:49 pm
This post is somewhat less coherent than authentic frontier gibberish.
melanie Lewis September 15, 2012 at 10:12 pm
Assault with a deadly tongue. Mental assault is criminal. Hope that clears up the gibber. But if I'm wrong. Hey it's just gibber anyway right?
melanie Lewis September 15, 2012 at 10:16 pm
In case someone really did miss my point, men aren't supposed to confront women, verbally or assault them. It's rude. It's unfair competition. The force used behind words from a heart of hatred, cruelty, and racial infused intolerance is deadlier than a not so coherent, girl with the street mentality less than that of a five year old.
Susan Schaefer September 15, 2012 at 10:48 pm
Sally, as a mom that recently dropped off a son at school, I completely understand your compulsion towards the cinnabon, although I am more of a slutty brownie girl myself. I also agree, life does need frosting every once in a while.
Molly September 16, 2012 at 10:12 am
So as we enter our junior year (high school) the criteria for school selection should not be majors, dorms or price but what food choices are available at the highway oasis. This means PA is out...not a Cinnabon n sight.
D'skidoc September 16, 2012 at 11:04 am
My friend got food poisoning from a Chinese buffet on the Pa Turnpike. Consider the school which is too far to drive. There is always a Cinnabon in the airport, and you can shoehorn yourself into one of those econonmy seats and have a sugar coma for 4 1/2 hours to ASU, whereupon exiting the aircraft (as the Mittster would say) the sugar in your arteries will instantly carmelize in the 116 deg. August heat.
D'skidoc September 16, 2012 at 11:06 am
Molly, there's always Food Science or culinary school, location tbd.
D'skidoc September 16, 2012 at 11:07 am
Or better yet, you could study nutrition.
melanie Lewis September 16, 2012 at 03:37 pm
Rats. Never eat from places like airports, etc. I worry about freshness and quality when it comes to consuming things that are left overnight in confined spaces. Especially ground level and lower levelled spots. UGH. Rat butt. Or worse. Open that bag of chips with caution. The myriad of smells alone is just bad. Proceed to Cinnabons with extreme caution. Now places like Northbrook Court, where it's so immaculately clean and shiny that you never second guess the freshness levels of foods, is priceless. Just saying.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Joe June 14, 2013 at 10:19 pm
What's an assault weapon Janna ?
Stu Pidasso June 15, 2013 at 02:10 am
Joe, your funny!! Assault Weapon... at a bar or on a date? I know some guys that have a dead weaponRead More when they try to assault :)
Ernest Makkai June 17, 2013 at 07:12 am
How do you conceal a four feet long assault weapon?
sibuna June 11, 2013 at 12:05 pm
Really? The community is going to be "shocked?" You assume an entire community not only isRead More interested in cosmetics, but that they are so interested in cosmestics that they are going to be "shocked" by an incredible team of experts. Dramatic much? Recommend
Sheryl Dineen June 12, 2013 at 11:48 am
How can I email this article to someone?